There's A Good Reason Why Judge Judy Quit

Calling It Quits

It had been going since 1996 and was a famous staple of the CBS line. 

So why, after nearly 25 years is Judge Judy suddenly leaving her financially comfy safe spot? Well, piecing together various interviews – and one big one from The Ellen DeGeneres Show – the answer is quite bittersweet.

Staple Of CBS

Even if someone hasn’t watched the long-running legal show, the name Judge Judy would still ring a very familiar bell in anyone’s head. 

It’s like Oprah. And even after such a long stint, the program was showing no signs of slowing down.

Never Losing Steam

It had aired nearly 7,300 episodes. She had also won three Daytime Emmy awards for Outstanding Legal/Courtroom Program over a four-year period from 2013.

 Maybe it was just an accumulation of stress? Judy Sheindlin kept no secrets about the various “bullets dodged” over her career.

Ups And Downs

Hosting a family court show on public television wasn’t without pressure. 

The law is meant to be even-handed but because people like her are dealing with human lives, there needs to be a counterbalance of common sense and “gut” feelings. Still, with a daily viewership of over 10 million, she’s ready to walk away.

The Beginning Of The End

It seems the first “straw on the camel’s back” came with something buried in her contract that she tried to execute.

 Judy was allowed to produce or make her own shows – something she was passionate about. She had a couple going on CBS that were doing quite well, but then the company did something unexpected.

Dropped Creatives

They dropped her shows for other programs that weren’t doing nearly as well but had “bigger” names. 

It was also rumored that her creative input was often cast aside – which was crazy because she was pulling in the highest Nielson ratings for a daytime television series for 5 years straight. The next tidbit gets even more shady.

Not Stopping

Even if Judge Judy is in her late 70s, she shows no signs of slowing down. 

More than anything she wanted to keep going. But with the silver anniversary of her “marriage” with CBS coming up, the company decided to do the unexpected with the rights to her rerun episodes. 

Rerun War

Judy held all the rights to all previous shows. 

She had also planned to sell them off to other stations for a dollar amount that had a boggling number of zeros behind the offer number. It turned out CBS wasn’t going to stand for it.

Easy Money

The station swopped in, and through tricky legal manoeuvres, bought the entire back-catalogue to sell on their own. 

“Out of respect” for her long career, they were going to let her finish out the season then stop running the cameras. After that, they were just going to monopolize on the 25 years of previous material. Judy has this to say...

"Good Luck"

“I wish them good luck with their experiment. But I’m not tired. So, [my new show] Judy Justice will be coming out [on a different network]. Judge Judy you’ll be able to see next year – all new shows.”

 So, it seems she will still keep the iconic boat floating. But what about the old staff?

Bringing The Family

Judy said herself that there will be people she will bring over from the old show. 

One important face is her bailiff, with whom she had an excellent on-camera rapport as well as an off-camera friendship. But there is also another program she wants to push.

New Shows

Aside from going to IMDb TV, which is part of Amazon, she’s also created a show called Her Honor. 

It’s a drama loosely based on her life – with plenty of glimpses into her life before she went in front of the camera. Judy also made a point about any rumors of retirement.

No Retirement 

“I’m not tired. I don’t play golf or tennis. I have no desire to learn how to play mah-jong, chess, or checkers. 

I know what I like to do. Why, at my stage in life, would I try to find something else when I already know what I like?” She goes on to explain about other aspects of her life...

Doing What She Loves

It’s not just her job she loves. Even if she will continue with her passions and media creativity, she is also still going to spend time with her children and grandchildren. Life will still come with stress, and she will “clean her home” to wind down.

There are, however, some interesting speculations that the public have unearthed that might lend to a secondary reason for the entire upheaval.

Yes, It’s A Set

Everyone is quite aware that the courtroom is simply a television set to look like it’s in New York (when it’s really in California) - complete with harsh attitude and equally harsh accents.

But there’s a level of fakeness that perhaps the Judge is getting tired of - or at least not being able to control so it’s not as superficial. It starts with the audience.

Paid Actors

There aren’t any family members crying in the background, hoping the verdict will go their way. There aren’t even those who are waiting for their turn. 

Everyone in the background has to send in a headshot and acting resume to be considered. If they get in, they’re paid 8 bucks an hour to pretend like they care about what’s going on in front of the cameras. 

Paid Outcomes

Since all the cases are small claims, the producers make a very enticing promise to the participants. 

If the defendants lose, the producers are the ones to pay the costs. That, plus a paid flight out to California makes it a win-win for everyone involved. Many people rely on this loophole to get out of paying under normal circumstances.

Fake Cases

It’s not just the lure of paid legal fees. 

Some people just wanted to be in front of the camera and get a free vacation. This was the case for four roommates who concocted a story around a cat and broken television. It wasn’t real at all. After the show aired, they even asked for appearance fees to anyone who wanted to interview them about the event.

She Knows Ahead Of Time

The questions are harsh and seem like they intended to peel away the layers of lies until the truth comes out.

However, each and every case is thoroughly reviewed by Judy ahead of time - to the point she knows that the verdict will be. She just asks the questions to keep the scene looking fresh.

Reality Vs. Television

Perhaps Judy is tired of the façade that goes along with her show? Maybe she doesn’t mind it and still loves to serve the law.

But the reality around her show has actually dug up some darker truths that raise some eyebrows.

Lives Ruined

While one case had her so moved that she went as far as to shut down an entire elementary school because it was so horrible, another case didn’t work out so well.

The producers made one man look “money hungry” (which wasn’t the case of his real personality), but it came across so bad on set that his friends and family believed it was true. Judy also accidentally outed the guy without permission.

“Great” Boss?

According to staff, Judy is a hard person to work for. But this can be taken with a grain of salt.

There were rumors of unwritten rules that, if broken, came with harsh consequences. For example, former staff said they weren’t allowed to make eye contact, talk with her, or ask “stupid” questions. 

Peer Pressure 

Many other non-television judges have made some pretty strong comments about Judy’s entire career.

She’s allegedly been labeled as rude and unprofessional, while Judy has apparently insisted it’s necessary sometimes to cut through the niceties. Some want her to dial back with the New York “mouth”, but she’s stayed strong to her approach. 

On-air Attitude 

One one hand, Judge Judy is known for being no-nonsense and straightforward.

But some people who appear on set just aren’t ready for how intense the experience can be. So, if we swirl all of this together, there seems to be another possible nudge for a new change of venue and format. 

Same Face, New Station

Still, don’t worry fans. Judge Judy isn’t going anywhere.

She’s just moving on to a platform that gives her a little more creative freedom. There will still be arguments, quippy comebacks, and quick sentences. The beloved face of law-television is here to stay.